I've seen a ton of questions posed regarding what to expect in the various forums online, whether here, or magic cafe, etc. An appreciable number of these accounts varied and in some cases, contradicted each other. This can be really frustrating -- particularly because after reading them all, one doesn't necessarily even feel more prepared for the legendary audition. In fact, the more of the various accounts that I read, the worse I felt. Eventually, the conclusion that I arrived at is that I'll never really know what it is that the judges expect unless I go in there and just do the audition; and after chickening out once already in July, I signed up for the audition in October and this time, I followed through and I passed. For me at least, it was nothing like how I thought it would be. Unless the person giving the account of what the AMA wants has auditioned there (and frankly, within the last 10 years), I'd take it with a grain of salt. That being said, my account of the audition starts out the same way as a lot of others, but there are some specific differences.
I checked in at the front desk with my application in hand. The sent me down to a room called The Inner Circle where I waited until about 7:30pm. At that point, they pulled applicants in to a room and conducted each audition one at a time until everyone was finished. For us, things wrapped up (I think) around 10pm. At that point, everyone finds out their results in private from the judges. Each judge came out and paired up with someone except for me and one other applicant. We were brought back in to the performance room and given the good news. Man, I was relieved and ecstatic! About what it takes to get in, I have a much better idea now and I hope what I say next puts your mind at ease. I wish someone would have told me this stuff before I pulled the trigger. The recipe I used:
* Prepare 5 tricks but expect to only do between 2-3 due to time constraints.
* Contrary to what people say, it *is* ok if they're all card tricks (straight from the horses mouth -- I asked after the audition was over).
* The tricks don't have to be overly technical and in fact one can be self working, but if you do not demonstrate any slight of hand in your audition at all, they won't pass you. That's what one of the judges told me after the audition.
* As soon as you walk in to the audition room to perform, make eye contact with the judges. Look them right in the eye and thank them for setting aside some time on a Monday night to consider you. In other words, show them respect -- after all, the collective experience in the room can probably be measured in centuries.
* Pick material that you're comfortable performing and that you could pretty much execute by reflex. If you need to make major adjustments to something, my *opinion* would be that you either don't make the adjustment if it's not crucial to the performance, or push off the audition by another month to get comfortable with whatever the change is. I heard someone once say that if you can't do it clean, don't do it.
* I recommend that you open with whatever you're best at. If you save your best stuff until the end, you may not get a chance to perform it.
* Dress well. Since the last suit I bought was back in 2006, I was due for a new one anyway, so I got fitted for a new one before the audition (and shoes, haha). One of the judges mentioned that they liked my shoes. Another mentioned that he liked my tie. I'm not saying that it's a make or break kind of thing, but they're apparently paying enough attention to say something about it.
* Above all, find a way to connect with the audience. My opinion is that this is the most important thing. Truly entertain them -- and there are plenty of ways to do that even if you're showing them a trick that they've already seen.
* The panel is on your side. They do want you to succeed. Of course they want more magicians to be members and pay dues.

They're hoping that you're the next one to write a check to the Magic Castle.
Last but not least, what I did. I opened my performance with a 4-card monte routine similar to the one by Dave Nabors. From there, I performed a silly production of a full deck of cards using something called "3D Advertising" by Henry Evans. From there, I did a 4 ace production where each spectator drew off about a quarter of the deck to reveal an ace at the top of each packet. From there, I went right in to Jazz Aces. After that, I reached in to my pocket for my silver dollars, planning to close with Daryl's version of 3-Fly-iii, but they cut me off and said that they'd seen enough to make a decision and sent me on my way. None of these routines are crazy, but I definitely nailed them hard and with my own patter. Oh and by the way, if you need to reset, they will allow that and (according to them) not hold it against you. They understand that people are super nervous and stressed out and some candidates may even be really intimidated -- I know I was. Hopefully this makes some of you feel better. It doesn't take miracles. Just be humble and professional. Connect with the audience and show that you care about magic and you'll do fine. Hope to see you all in the hallways of the Castle sometime. Cheers.