Michael:
Let me start by saying that I wouldn't be doing this if I didn't think that you and others can learn from it. I could have easily just have typed "good job man!"
The routine is obviously a work in progress and this is my second time doing it in front of an audience, so I appreciate your thoughts.
I have three questions: 1) Did you take the time to write down the patter? and 2) How many times have you rehearsed the routine, including patter, by yourself? I'm guessing the answers are no and none.
That leads me to: 3) How can anyone perform something they haven't scripted and rehearsed?
We all get to think we are better than others and that the rules don't apply. We think that we can pull together something at the last minute and pull it off without rehearsing. It can be done, but it can't be done well. Script, Practice, Rehearse, Perform.
I must admit, however, I don't really agree that I have a lack of presence or personality. I'm at least a far cry from those monotonous kids who simply narrate their action.
What I was trying to convey is that you have a personality but there was nothing in your performance that reflected it. The only things you said that were not a description of what was happening was the "preferable female" comment at the beginning, the "was it good for you?" comment right before the reveal and the "sexy music" comment during the recap. Everything else you said was "narrating" your action.
I'll give you credit for using the blank cards and the music. You've started to make the routine yours. But even with the addition of those two ideas, your dialogue is barely more than narration.
You have a great personality and presence in your other videos. However, your personality and presence is too big for a simple Youtube video. You need to bring that personality on stage where it would be the right size.
I admit the routine needs something more to it than a systematic approach, but keep in mind it's brand new and I'm still testing it on audiences to fine-tune it and get it right. As it stands, I'm an actor without a script. But, given that I plan on earning my living as a playwright, I can definitely whip something up.
Saying "this is new" is an excuse. The script is something that should have been done before the first performance, especially for a stage performance. Once you write something, I'd be glad to review it and give you my comments and feedback.
I didn't feel the need to do anything more than I did for this particular crowd. The show I performed this in was very fluffy and to-the-point. I usually approach my magic, typically my stage based work, as though I'm creating a one-act play... But for this type of atmosphere, I feel it would have felt overdone.
I can't see how a well scripted routine could be overdone. The key with a script, especially comedy, is to perform it in a way that makes it seem spontaneous. A script wouldn't have made it any longer or more in depth. Instead, it would have made what you said more interesting.
The audience seemed to enjoy it as it was and that's all I wanted in that moment.
My point is that they could have enjoyed it MORE.
I think you had plenty of good comedy in there which is better than cracking some lame-ass joke every two seconds and that way you can still preserve that moment of omgwtfbbq without it taking a seat behind comedy.
How many laughs do you think he got in his five minute performance?
Let's count - A half laugh at his "preferably female" comment, a laugh that was caused by the spectator's reaction to his bite down comment (they weren't laughing at his comment but her reaction), a laugh when he put it between his teeth and talking, a laugh at the spectator's reaction when he said "we'll see if there is any magic between us"; a laugh when he put on the music, a half laugh when he asked "was it good for you?" and a laugh when he referred to the music as "sexy music." That's four laughs for him and two for the spectator's reaction.
Even if we give him full credit, that is six laughs in five minutes -- any comedian who gets that number of laughs would not be asked back (an average comedian can get 4 to 6 laughs PER MINUTE).
what you and i both have to realize is that you have their full attention and you don't need to conform to what they want just say what you have to say and don't worry about what the spectators think.
The better thing is to have a script that the spectators want to hear.