Tell me what you think of this ;)

[Sinful07]

Unnecessary

That itself was a bit unnecessary as well wasnt it- And to add, Steerpike does have a valid point. He wanted Feedback, he gave legit and very descriptive criticism.

 

[Nikhil Kumar]

well all I can say is, He did what he was said to do, give feedback whether I like it or not.. I take his feedback as his opinion rather than I should do professionally, while I appreciate all comments including Steerpike's, before he criticizes, it would be cool to see a video of his own.

 

[Steerpike]

before he criticizes, it would be cool to see a video of his own.

And that would prove what exactly? The space-time continuum would warp and make my advice suddenly true where it wasn't before? I find it a little odd that people seem to think I need to produce a Palm d'Or or a Golden Globe in order to be able to dispense good advice when it comes to the fundamentals of good cinematography and editing.

God, why do I waste my time? Why do I ****ing bother?

 

[visualartist]

And that would prove what exactly? The space-time continuum would warp and make my advice suddenly true where it wasn't before? I find it a little odd that people seem to think I need a produce a Palm d'Or in order to be able to dispense good advice when it comes to the fundamentals of good cinematography and editing.

God, why do I waste my time? Why do I ****ing bother?

I wouldnt expect many people here to know what Palm d'Or is.
What people dont know is that Steerpike is in fact a director.He knows what he's talking about.
And besides,he was not attacking saying that he can do it better.
You dont need to know how to act to recognize a bad actor. He's trying to help you.Why challenge him?


P.S. You say before he criticizes youd like to see a video of his own.So are you going to say that to everybody that critiques you at something?

 

[Sinful07]

God, why do I waste my time? Why do I ****ing bother?

Probably cause you're bored, Or you have some twisted agenda regarding the magic community. Dont know, Dont really care.

well all I can say is, He did what he was said to do, give feedback whether I like it or not.. I take his feedback as his opinion rather than I should do professionally, while I appreciate all comments including Steerpike's, before he criticizes, it would be cool to see a video of his own.

There was a video of him posted earlier in this thread. Not to ass kiss, but you can tell from his posts that he oozes of experience- and you dont need that video to show it.

Sometimes i dont understand why you bother steer- I dont.

 

[Nikhil Kumar]

I appriciate that he spent time analysing my video. I'm not trying to challenge him in anyway. There is room for improvement ofcourse.

Stop taking the wrong impression that I am not greatful for the advise, I was just joking when I was saying them things before.

 

[Steerpike]

I was just joking when I was saying them things before.

Jokes generally have these things called punchlines, and unless I was meant to be it...

My reaction comes from the fact that an all-too-common response to criticism is, "I don't see you doing any better." I once tried to give a writer advice and they demanded to see my work before they'd accept my criticism. I showed them my screenplays, and they immediately said that didn't count, as if a screenwriter knows nothing about prose. They also badmouthed my writing without actually criticizing in an attempt to prove they were too good for my advice.